Just as Athena sprang fully grown and fully armed from the head of Zeus, a finished photo appeared to me the moment I glanced through the car window. The golden light was perfect on the huge tree stump, contrasting with the distant shadows.
Oto was getting out of his seat, eager to get inside the house, but I asked him to hop up on the stump while I grabbed a phone shot. I’m seldom on duty anymore, so I thought a phone snap would suffice for family scrolling.
Quick iPhone Photo at Golden Hour
Later, I heard the story of the neighbor, Ken, who as a young child had mowed the grass around what was then a small sapling. He had wanted to run right over it to make mowing easier, but was not allowed.
The next day, I asked if I could photograph him with the stump that had grown from that very sapling. He kindly agreed but was available only until 5 PM, when the sky was cloudy and well before golden hour. Oto was out sailing, so I worked with just Ken, who struck several poses.
A photographer knows while shooting what he’s getting. The light was nice and soft but wrong for my intent. Maybe a combination of photos would work, since the photo of Ken alone was nothing special.
Cloudy Overcast Pro Camera Capture
On a large computer screen, Oto’s photo held up only briefly. Careful examination revealed excessive sharpening and color boosting. The plasticky look of computational photography, programmed into every phone photo, makes images look good at first glance but can also make them look fake.
The pro camera photos were technically exquisite, with realistic color and texture. The light was just the light, illuminating but not glowing. I had not worked the scene well, since even the best of the poses was uninspired.
It bothered me professionally that I hadn’t taken the time to grab a camera for the afternoon shot. This is why I never want to hear “the best camera is the camera you have with you.” The best camera is the best camera.
The two photos side by side carry some weight and perhaps salvage my intent. You can read what you like into the symbolism: a new sapling on an old stump, or a man still standing though the sapling of his youth is gone forever.
Compare & Contrast
For many things in life, good enough is good enough. Photographers often agonize over details that others barely notice but that would improve the photo in the photographer’s eyes. Even the combination of these photos might never get past the exploration stage, so in this case photography can learn something from life.